Can You Get Evicted For Not Having Renters Insurance? 

It might come as a shock, but skipping out on renters insurance could lead to serious financial and legal implications. In fact, if your lease says renters insurance is a must and you don’t get it, your landlord could issue an eviction notice for breaking the lease terms. 

Let’s unpack why understanding your lease agreement is crucial, and how having renters insurance can help you stay compliant and avoid potential eviction.

Who needs renters insurance?

You’ll need to sign up for renters insurance if it’s listed as a requirement in your lease agreement. Even if it’s not mandatory for your lease, renters insurance is a smart choice to protect your personal property (aka your stuff) against a lot of bad things that can happen to it—like theft, vandalism, and fires.

Picture this: you come home after a long day at work ready to binge-watch some TV, only to find your front door unlocked and your brand-new 75-inch flat-screen TV stolen from your living room. Without renters insurance, you’d be stuck shouldering the full cost of replacing your favorite source of entertainment.

If you had renters insurance in this scenario, your insurance company would step in to help cover the cost of replacing your TV—minus your deductible—on eligible claims, saving you from a stressful financial hit. 

Is renters insurance required by law? 

No, there aren’t any federal or state laws that make renters insurance mandatory for tenants, but landlords can require it as part of the rental agreement. So, getting renters insurance might be a condition for renting, just like paying a security deposit or meeting other lease terms such as a no-pets policy.

Be sure to read the terms of your lease agreement carefully to check if renters insurance is required.

Can my landlord force me to get renters insurance?

Yes, your landlord may require renters insurance as part of the lease agreement. This condition is entirely legal and often included to protect both you and the landlord. Here’s why landlords value renters insurance:

1. Protection for tenants’ belongings: Landlord insurance typically covers structural damage to the building but not tenants’ personal property. Requiring renters insurance ensures tenants have coverage for their possessions. 
2. Reduced liability for landlords: Renters insurance reduces the chances of tenants suing landlords over incidents like theft, fire, or injury-related claims. 
3. Fewer relocation costs: Renters insurance with additional living expenses coverage can help pay for displaced tenants’ housing costs, reducing the landlord’s financial burden. 

Before signing a lease, check whether renters insurance is a requirement. Non-compliance could lead to penalties or even an eviction notice.

Can I get evicted if my roommate has renters insurance, but I don’t?

If your lease says you need renters insurance, don’t count on your roommate’s policy to cover you. Without your own coverage, you could end up facing some serious risks—including eviction.

Renters insurance is typically structured to cover only the policyholder’s personal property and liability, meaning each roommate will need to purchase their own renters insurance policy to make sure they’re covered. The best approach? Get your own renters insurance policy to make sure your personal belongings, liability, and legal interests are properly protected. 

What if I live with family members? 

If you live with your family, aka anyone living in your home and related to you by marriage, blood, or adoption, they may be covered under your policy automatically for no extra fee. 

Just remember, living with family members might mean you’ll need to bump up your coverage limits. What works to protect your stuff alone might not be enough to cover both you and others covered by your policy, so it’s a good idea to review your policy and make coverage adjustments as needed.

What if I live with my significant other? 

By default, your policy won’t cover your significant other if you aren’t married. However, you can easily add them as an “additional insured” for a small additional cost. 

If you choose to share a policy, be sure your personal property coverage limit is high enough to protect both of your belongings. That said, it’s worth considering that it might be cheaper—and more convenient—for each of you to have separate renters insurance policies.

What are other risks of not having renters insurance?

Skipping renters insurance can expose you to several financial risks, including:

1. Unprotected personal belongings: Without renters insurance, you’re responsible for the costs to repair or replace your stolen or damaged personal property. Events like theft, water damage, or vandalism could leave you with steep, out-of-pocket expenses. 
2. No liability protection: Accidents happen. If someone who doesn’t live with you is injured in your rental unit or if you unintentionally damage a neighbor’s property (like if your bathtub overflows into your downstairs neighbor’s apartment), you could end up on the hook for medical or repair expenses. 
3. No additional living expenses (aka loss of use coverage): If your rental unit becomes uninhabitable due to an event like a fire, you’ll cover any hotel stays or temporary housing out of your own pocket. Loss of use coverage could save you substantial costs in these scenarios. 

Ultimately, renters insurance provides a safety net against life’s unexpected curveballs.

How will my landlord know I have renters insurance?

Landlords often ask to be added as an “interested party” or “additional interest” on your renters insurance. This just means they’ll get notified if you cancel or make big changes to your policy. It doesn’t cost anything to add them, and it keeps things clear between you and your landlord.

Adding an interested party to your renters insurance policy is usually pretty simple, but the process can depend on your insurance provider. 

At Lemonade, you can add your interested party or parties in seconds on our mobile app. Just tap the “add interested party/landlord” icon on the homepage of your renters policy and fill in a few details, including:

• Your interested party’s name
• Your interested party’s email address
• The address for your apartment
• The address for your leasing office, landlord, or your landlord’s management company

Adding an interested party lets your landlord keep an eye on insurance compliance without getting involved in your policy.

Keep in mind: If your landlord requires that you buy a renters insurance policy, you’ll likely need to provide proof of insurance (such as a declaration page) before your move-in date. Without proof of insurance, your landlord may not let you move in. 

Why should tenants get renters insurance even if it’s not required?

Renters insurance helps protect tenants from unexpected events like theft, fire, or property damage. Some people think it’s only worth it if you have pricey stuff, but the truth is, it’s useful for anyone renting a home or apartment. Here’s why:

1. Affordable peace of mind: Renters insurance policies are relatively inexpensive, with Lemonade renters insurance policies starting as low as $5 per month. This small investment provides financial protection for your belongings and liability. 
2. Financial protection against surprises: Life is unpredictable. Renters insurance covers the cost of repairing or replacing your belongings if they’re stolen or damaged due to a covered event, pays for repairs if you accidentally cause damage to someone else’s property, and can even support hotel expenses, above your normal cost of living, a covered loss leaves your rental uninhabitable. Without it, you could be left to handle these expenses on your own.
3. Liability coverage for mishaps: If someone who doesn’t live with you gets injured in your rental—such as a visiting friend tripping over a rug and breaking their ankle—renters insurance can help cover their medical bills. It ensures you’re not stuck footing the bill for accidents that happen under your roof.
4. Coverage for small incidents that add up: Sometimes, it’s the small losses that hit hardest—like replacing your laptop after it’s stolen from your car or needing to buy a new espresso machine that was damaged in a small kitchen fire. Renters insurance can step in to help with situations like this, too.

At the very least, it’s worth considering renters insurance if your lease mandates it—or if you want peace of mind that your belongings are protected.

Before we go… 

For renters, securing renters insurance offers reliable protection for personal belongings, liability, and unexpected living expenses. And while renters insurance isn’t legally required, skipping it can lead to financial risks, and failure to comply with lease requirements could even result in eviction.

If you’re searching for affordable and comprehensive renters insurance, get a quote today—and take the first step toward peace of mind in your rental living experience.

FAQs*

*This information is intended for general purposes only and should not be considered legal advice. Landlord-tenant laws can differ significantly based on your location. For specific legal guidance regarding landlord-tenant disputes, it is best to consult a qualified attorney.

---

A few quick words, because we <3 our lawyers: This post is general in nature, and any statement in it doesn’t alter the terms, conditions, exclusions, or limitations of policies issued by Lemonade, which differ according to your state of residence. You’re encouraged to discuss your specific circumstances with your own professional advisors. The purpose of this post is merely to provide you with info and insights you can use to make such discussions more productive! Naturally, all comments by, or references to, third parties represent their own views, and Lemonade assumes no responsibility for them. Coverage and discounts may not be available in all states.